Tuesday, July 27, 2021

MOVE’s children: how parents are controlled so that children are property of MOVE

by Maiga Milbourne

A number of people keep asking about the significance of John Gilbride. Honestly, the question stings. John Gilbride was married to the leader of MOVE, Alberta Africa. He is the father of a MOVE child, Zack Africa. He was in MOVE the same way as Kevin and I and any other supporter. He dedicated his life to MOVE. He was there for years. He lived at MOVE’s Kingsessing Ave. headquarters with Alberta as people like Ria, Consuewella, and Ramona were just coming home from prison. Everyone who was around at that time knew him.

And he was murdered.


How can that not matter? How can he not matter?


Significantly, he was a father of a child in MOVE. Parents being separated from their children in MOVE is one of the many throughlines between his murder and Pixie (June)’s escape. 


In recent months, I’ve come to understand some patterns.


John Africa recruited women. Women MOVE members were meant to pull in men. Even better, single mothers were the perfect MOVE members. There were a number of them in the early days of MOVE and a number of women in recent times became single mothers when their husbands were driven from the organization. 


John Africa wanted their children. He fed the children MOVE’s raw food diet, ensured they were not educated, kept them outside in all weather, and indoctrinated them to MOVE’s beliefs. He was trying to create a “perfect” human through his experiment.


Fathers, or any parents who dissented and had the ability to push back, were threats. The recent “Murder at Ryan’s Run” podcast recounts Andino Ward, father of Oyewolffe AKA Birdie Africa, being repeatedly attacked for trying to see his son.


I came around MOVE when the custody battle between John Gilbride and Alberta Africa was at a fever pitch. At that time, it was told to me as an intersectional Black feminist struggle. Alberta Africa was the Black mother defending her child against an arrogant and potentially dangerous white man. I was 21 and I didn’t do my own research. The claims made about John and his family were ludicrous and easily disproven.


John tried to play by the rules. He left quietly. He then filed for divorce and custody. Alberta wouldn’t allow John to even have private visitation with his son. The courts, however, did grant John visitation. And the night before John had a court-ordered unsupervised visit with his son, he was gunned down in his car.


June, Whit, and the other young women in MOVE were pushed into early marriages. Ria and Bert said things like, “they’re fast (meaning promiscuous. June was 12 when this unfounded, untrue, and dangerous claim was made). They’ll cause trouble if they’re not married.” They were pushed into multiple pregnancies because that kept them busy. They were creating children for MOVE. They were expected to have their children ready to perform at every program or sanctioned protest. They were expected to bring their children into MOVE headquarters, as it was boarded up and headed into a possible confrontation during the custody battle in 2002. 


At various points when these MOVE-born parents pushed back against Ria and Bert, they were repeatedly told: “these are not your children. These are MOVE children.” 


The same that Andino was told. The same that John was told. The same that so many others were told.


This is why when June left, she took her children. Same as Val before her. Those who took their children kept their children. Those who left without their children lost them to MOVE.


Supporters received opposite messaging. Shortly after John was killed, white supporters Tony and Lori, who had a toddler, publicly left MOVE. Ria would say all the time that having a child had activated “system training” in them. That MOVE supporters never stayed after they had children and their marriages didn’t last either. The mandate was to “stay in MOVE” and “get strong,” meaning, be blindly dedicated to Ria and Bert’s whims.


In my 20s, I didn’t feel ready to have children so the recommendation sat fine with me. Other supporters, like Ellie and Bob, had children and quietly left. Each time this happened it was used as an example of the dangers of becoming parents.


What I didn’t know at the time is that experiencing pregnancy and parenthood in MOVE exposed you much more quickly to the evils and corruption within the cult. Because I didn’t have children of my own, I only knew the rhetoric, not the reality. Given that the espoused belief is “life” I thought both that the pregnancies were desired (maybe sometimes accidental, but still wanted) and that pregnant and birthing parents were treated with care and respect.


Nothing was further from the truth.


Some supporters never had children. Ria would say that John Africa taught that menopause isn’t real and doesn’t apply to MOVE women. She is in her 70s but said that she would have another child.


Some supporters would try to wait as long as Ria and Bert dictated only to find that their childbearing years had passed and that they were no longer able to become parents. Other couples were pitted against one another, where one partner would privately sabotage conception based on Ria and Bert’s dictates.


As I lived into my 30s, I began to want children. 


Alberta would say tone-deaf things to me like, “why don’t you just adopt?” I would explain how costly adoption is and she would shrug. She often seemed oblivious to these types of realities. Obviously, adoption is a laudable act and one I consider for myself. However, at that time, I was telling Bert that I wanted the experience of pregnancy and birth if it was available to me, and she was callously dismissing that.


Ria continuously said not to get pregnant. Finally, I told her that if I continued to heed her advice and the window of opportunity passed for me, I would resent her and resent MOVE. She couldn’t get around that.


When I did get pregnant, it was like a switch was hit with Ria and Bert. They treated me completely differently. They were used to me attending to their needs and being on call to take them places. My priority was my growing child so I couldn’t be at their beck and call. I began to save the abusive voicemails that I received from Ria or shared them with other MOVE members so that she couldn’t invent lies about me.


The first thing that Bert said to me, on the phone, when I shared the news of the pregnancy, was “I’ll come over and babysit.” Something in me went cold and I knew that I would never allow her access to my child.


When I did go down to be around Ria, I would be put in unsafe situations. At that time, Ria was constantly warring with a young MOVE member in his early 20s. On multiple occasions, they would get in public screaming matches on the streets of Philadelphia. Ria is a white woman in her 70s and this was a young Black man with locks. No one on the street knew they considered themselves family. On several occasions, I was terrified that a physical fight would break out. I was pregnant, so I couldn’t intervene. I would call June afterward. I was so bewildered that they would endanger me when I was pregnant. I actually think that my being pregnant escalated Ria. She and Bert really seem to hate pregnant women.


I did my best to avoid being around MOVE leadership in my pregnancy. I still called Ria once a week as I had for years. Usually, she complained and berated me. I was doing my best to keep my mind peaceful (what I thought was MOVE’s belief) and aligned towards birthing my daughter. I remember that I was about 38 weeks pregnant in the beginning of June 2019 and went for a walk. I sat on a bench under a pine tree and called Ria. Janet and Janine had recently come home from prison. I was really happy that they were home and trying to steer the conversation towards celebrating that victory. Ria began yelling at me, “you and Kevin are SO diplomatic! You want to support Debbie and Mike. You’re SO liberal. You won’t choose sides.”


Finally, I just said, “I have to go.” I hung up the phone and that was the last time that I spoke with her.


Shortly after, Kevin wrote an open letter to MOVE explaining how these types of dynamics were unhealthy and we were unwilling to be a part of them. He made sure that everyone in the organization received it so that again, Bert and Ria couldn’t lie.


I now understand that young people in MOVE are forced into early parenthood to control them. Supporters are kept from parenthood to control them. The ultimate design is to have full access to the children to continue John Africa’s mission of “creating” a perfect being. MOVE always said, “application don’t need no conversation” meaning that you see the truth of the belief in the evidence.


This is the evidence: there were five children killed on Osage Ave. who never should have been brought into that house, the harassment and intimidation campaign against John Gilbride and his family fits a pattern that repeats throughout MOVE's history, six people who were born into MOVE are coming forward with stories of systemic abuse that they have only begun to reveal. The survivors who were born in are escaping and telling the story to protect those who remain.


Maiga Milbourne was a dedicated MOVE supporter from 2002-2018. She distanced herself from the group as she began to note troubling patterns within MOVE. In 2021, June Stokes AKA Pixie Africa disclosed severe abuse suffered within MOVE. Together with Maiga’s husband Kevin Price, “Murder at Ryan’s Run” podcast producer Beth McNamara, podcast researcher Bob Helms, and former MOVE members Josh and Whit Robbins, a plan was crafted where June publicly left MOVE with her 5 children and went into hiding. Publicity from both the podcast and this blog has been used to keep her and her children safe.


MOVE Leader Ria (Sue Africa) with Maiga Milbourne

Monday, July 26, 2021

In June of 2018, Mona had a stroke and Debbie came home

by Maiga Milbourne

In mid-June of 2018, it felt like the world turned on its axis.

On Thursday, June 14, Ramona Africa was hospitalized for a stroke, lymphoma, and diabetes.


Two days later, on June 16, Debbie Africa was the first of the MOVE 9 to be released from prison after 40 years.


At that time, I was a committed MOVE supporter but I was noting serious issues within the organization. Based on the information that I had, I thought that most of the interpersonal issues that I was witnessing were the result of trauma. I was closest to Ria (Sue) and would often try to gently talk to her about giving more decision-making power to the younger generation-- specifically to people like Mike Jr, June (Pixie), and others who were already fully adults with many responsibilities within the organization. I offered that she and Bert could be more cared for and that shifting some of those dynamics would likely give them more relief and give the next generation more agency.


These conversations fell on deaf ears and I was increasingly troubled by what I was seeing within the organization.


I would come down to West Philly from my home in South Jersey about twice a week. It was a big commitment as it’s a half-hour drive each way and was generally in the middle of the day. This ritual was grandfathered in over the years. Ria had come to count on me to take her to run errands (she, and many in the organization, do not drive), get groceries, go sit in coffee houses, and talk. It was equally common for me to pick up Ria and whoever she might throw in my car outside the house or to go in. In the spring of 2018, there was increasing animosity between Ria and Bert, and Mike Jr., and those who allied themselves with him. Ria would often tell me rumors suggesting that Mike Jr. was no longer a loyal nor reliable MOVE member. I would try to sort out what I was hearing but it basically amounted to Ria and Bert being angry that Mike Jr. was working closely with producer Tommy Oliver and lawyers Bret Grote and Brad Thomson to release his parents, Debbie and Mike Sr of the MOVE 9. Of course, his efforts were also to benefit all of the MOVE 9.


MOVE supporters, according to Ria and Bert, were meant to come around the MOVE organization to assist in the liberation of the MOVE 9. That was the stated goal. It was our job to be activists and educators on the MOVE 9 and what had lead to their incarceration: the history of August 8, 1978, the issues they addressed as MOVE members in Powelton village, and the activist work they came to do as political prisoners. That meant we regularly visited all of the MOVE 9 where we would spend hours in conversation enjoying each other's company. We would write letters to them. We would be their advocates within activist and organizing circles on the outside.


Ria suggesting to me that Mike Jr. bringing his parents home was a problem was an immediate and huge red flag. She kept trying to create an argument that would in any way make sense, but she couldn’t spin this. She would say that John Africa said that Mumia was meant to come home through the courts and the MOVE 9 through the power of the people. But John Africa had also said that no Philly sports team would win a title while the MOVE 9 were in prison, and the Philadelphia Phillies won the world series in 2008 so I didn’t have much stock in that prophecy.


I would counter with arguments like: but we don’t believe in prisons. Ramona had told a story for years that she was put in jail over a weekend in the early days of MOVE. When she got there, she was kind of comfortable and enjoying spending time with other MOVE members, and when she was being bailed out she told her family that it was fine, she’d stay in jail with her sisters for the weekend. Something happened and she got a much longer hit and had to stay in jail for many more months. She always told it as a cautionary tale that no one should allow themselves to be imprisoned if they could help it.


Ria would hem and haw and ultimately say that I wouldn’t understand.


Meanwhile, Ramona was having serious medical issues and had for years. It was being hidden by the larger organization. At a program at the Rotunda, MOVE men brought Ramona in as she couldn’t walk the steps herself and then sat her behind the merchandise table for the entirety of the evening. I sat with her and remember overhearing other people saying how humble she was to be at the merchandise table. She was there because she couldn’t walk.


With June, Kevin, and many other MOVE members pushing Ria and Bert, they finally and reluctantly took her to an urgent care. The doctor thought it was possible lymphoma and urged a spleen test. Ria was in hysterics. She didn’t want that procedure to happen. 


People in the organization would call Kevin and me as though we were medical experts and ask for our advice. We continuously said, “do the test. Get immediate care for her. If it IS lymphoma, time is of the essence.”


I know that June and others in the organization were saying the same. But MOVE's belief is that all medical ailments are “mental,” meaning in the mind, and so Ria and Bert maintained that if Mona “did her work,” meaning somehow fixed her mind to heal lymphoma, that no action would be necessary. However, there are serious inconsistencies in when MOVE’s belief is applied in this way as Alberta has had many medical procedures, some of which were elective. The denial of medical care for Ramona functioned similarly to the denial of medical care for June and other young women, as punishment. 


That spring I contracted Lyme disease and was away from MOVE for a few weeks while I recuperated. I was finally well enough to come down in mid-June. This meant that it had been weeks since I had seen Mona.


Ria asked me down on Thursday, June 14. I was going to come before Kevin and I were both away for the weekend. He had planned a rock climbing trip in New Hampshire with some friends. At that time, I taught yoga full time and lead yoga retreats. A retreat center in Maine had invited me to view their venue so I was taking a friend and fellow yoga teacher up with me to see the retreat center.


On Thursday, June 14, I came down to MOVE headquarters. Ria asked me in to see Mona. Mona was sitting on the porch and was clearly dying. June was tending to her and obviously distraught. She had been begging for Mona to get medical care for months and no one would listen to her. Carlos was there. He seemed distracted and avoidant. I remember him sitting by Mona and shelling peanuts.


Half of Mona’s face was sagging. She kept mumbling incoherently about the sun. She had lost a tremendous amount of weight and looked like a pile of bones within her nightgown. Her feet and ankles were grotesquely swollen with ashy, dry skin stretched overtop.


Ria said we should go. I got Ria into the car and said, “Mona needs to go to a hospital. Do you want me to drive her or should I call the ambulance?”


Ria didn’t fight me-- which was significant-- but also wouldn’t act. She told me to go to the coffee shop. I was terrified but I thought I might have more success if I got her on my side. I didn’t know what would happen if an ambulance just showed up at MOVE headquarters. It seemed like that might be worse for Mona because MOVE people might fight them and then become more obstinate in her treatment.


I took Ria to United by Blue on Walnut street in West Philly. I heard her speaking on the phone, I assume to Bert. Ria was sort of talking through, both on the phone and with me, the implications of getting Mona treatment. I tried to stay calm and gentle but did my best to convey urgency. We finally went back to the house-- I think after two hours!-- and Ria elected to call Mona’s mother to take her to the hospital. I told her that I was staying until she went to the hospital. I was scared that if I left they wouldn’t take her. It's worth emphasizing the June and other MOVE members had been insisting that Mona needed to go to the hospital for months and that she likely only listened to me because I am white.


I was glad that I did stay. Mona’s mother was doing childcare and arrived right away but with a car full of children. (She also had been deeply worried for months and pushing for medical care.) She didn’t have room for Mona in her car. I said I could drive Mona or we could call an ambulance.


There was a lot more deliberating, as Mona sat dying on that porch. Finally, they agreed to use my car. June, Ria, Carlos, and I carried Mona into my car. Carlos and June came as I drove to Penn hospital and Mona’s mother followed behind. Carlos and June brought Mona into the hospital. It was a blessing that June was there as she was able to advocate. She was Mona’s primary medical point person and did a tremendous job. June is responsible for several MOVE members being alive when leadership behaved as though they wanted them to die from medical neglect.


At that point, I was told to go home. I wasn’t family so I couldn’t get in. Penn had recognized Mona as having an active stroke and immediately admitted her. They said she would have died had she not been seen quickly.


In the months that followed the physicians explained how the undiagnosed and untreated lymphoma had lead to several previous mini-strokes and the stroke that she suffered on that June 14 day.


I remember calling Kevin, in shock. He had a backpack strapped on his back and was walking through Manhattan to wait in a friend’s apartment until the group met to drive to New England. Thankfully, that friend is a physician who advised us, over the phone, through many medical decisions that weekend.


Ria told me to go to Maine. I wouldn’t be able to see Mona for a few days anyway.


I gathered my friend and we drove north. We arrived the evening of June 15.


On the morning of June 16, I was sitting on the steps of the retreat center in Maine drinking coffee. Kevin called. Mike Jr. had Debbie in his car and they were driving away from Cambridge Springs prison. Debbie had called Kevin on the drive from SCI-Cambridge Springs. He still has the message on his phone. 


I couldn’t believe it. I knew Ria had said that she might be released in the coming weeks but I had no knowledge of when nor if it would happen.


And it felt like this rip in the fabric of the universe. Mona was in the hospital and might not survive the multiple conditions she was suffering. And Debbie was home.


There’s so much more to say about all of this and that period in time. As Mona stabilized, everyone in the organization took shifts to sit with her first at the hospital and later at various rehab centers. June was a primary organizer of this care. Kevin and I took many shifts a week, making meals for Mona, and sitting with her. All of us took turns staying with Mona overnight, making sure she was safe in the hospital and rehab center.


There’s a lot to say about what care was permitted and what wasn’t. It often felt like Mona’s health was being purposefully sabotaged by leadership. It was in those desperate conversations with June that Kevin and I began learning about corruption in the organization that we had never previously imagined. This was the foundation of a new level of trust and closeness with June and a much greater awareness that MOVE leadership wasn’t simply traumatized but criminal.


When I came home from Maine, I sat with Mona. Afterward, I was so excited to go see Debbie. I had met her many times on visits in prison but never on the outside. I called Ria and asked if I could take her to see Debbie. It was policy, for Ria and Bert, to not see Debbie. (They later did but under very strange, strained conditions.) Ria kept saying that one day I would understand. There was nothing that could make me understand. Debbie had done 40 years in prison. MOVE said they believed in family. MOVE prided itself on not falling prey to the COINTELPRO tactics that split apart groups like the Black Panthers. MOVE counseled other groups on never turning on one another.


I kept asking, what could possibly be the reason to not see her? Ria would evade and finally say, “well, she didn’t tell Janet and Janine that she was leaving.” And “Mike Jr didn’t tell me and Bert.” I soon understood that there were very good reasons for Mike Jr. to keep this information hidden, as he had every reason to believe that Ria and Bert had done everything in their power to keep his parents in prison. 


No one could say anything. It was a sensitive deal to get Debbie released and her release paved the way for the rest of the MOVE 9 to come home. And yet, these were the petty reasons that I was given.


My perspective is that Ria and Bert were mad. Debbie’s release was not sanctioned or planned by them. They fought Mike Jr’s actions on behalf of his parents tooth and nail. They continuously said that John Africa said they wouldn’t come home this way. Though they always claimed publicly that John Africa prophesized that the MOVE 9 would come home in victory, they privately told others that the MOVE 9 were never supposed to come home at all. I think that for Mike Jr., Pam, and many others, their organizing efforts to get the MOVE 9 released were sincere and legitimate, but ultimately Ria and Bert sabotaged possibilities for their release. 


I think the truth is that they didn’t want the MOVE 9 to ever come home. As long as the MOVE 9 were incarcerated, they had a cause. They had an activity to draw supporters to them. The machine was well-oiled. Supporters fight for the freedom of the MOVE 9. They go to prisons and write letters. They talk about MOVE at activist events. MOVE has a cause. They have a reason to fundraise.


With the MOVE 9 home, they lost all of that relevance. As a new supporter, I thought MOVE people would return to the activities they had engaged in prior to the incarceration of the MOVE 9. I thought they would educate about anti-racist action, healthy and simple living, and the rest of MOVE belief tenets. But they were so far from living in that way and Ria and Bert, for certain, showed no interest in returning to that lifestyle. 


For me, that’s when I internally left, though I didn’t fully distance myself for another year. I couldn’t accept Debbie being shunned after serving a 40-year prison sentence. I couldn’t believe the medical neglect and torture of Mona. For years, I had dreamed of the MOVE 9 coming home. I had cried about it and imagined it as a moment of such hope. That the activist community would use this triumph to galvanize us to do so much more good work in the world. I watched the MOVE 9 come home, one by one, and see this moment absolutely squandered, while the internal organization continued to fracture. Reluctantly, there were a few press conferences. 


I had talked to Eddie and Mumia in the summer of 2018, while they were both still incarcerated at Mahanoy. We gently explained that Ria and Bert hadn’t spoken to Mike Jr. in months over his work on behalf of his parents. Eddie scoffed and said, “when I get home I’ll sort all of that out.” 


When he got home, he went into MOVE headquarters and after, towed their line. He, Janet, and Janine have closely allied themselves with Ria and Bert. June has often said that many of the young people in MOVE hoped that when the MOVE 9 came home that they would save them from the abuse they suffered. Instead there was just more of the same. Those loyal to Ria and Bert now call themselves the “original MOVE members.” Debbie and Mike Sr live on their own. The groups don’t comingle. 


Sadly, Chuck Africa was abandoned by Ria and Bert many years ago. Kevin recalls Ria telling him, at least seven years ago, that Chuck was working with the police. Kevin knew at the time that this was a lie and that Chuck was far more loyal to the ideals of MOVE than Ria and Bert. Chuck was denied the support of the well-funded faction of the Organization while he was most in need of emotional support and medical care. 


Debbie and Mike Sr. came to see my daughter a few times as a little baby. She loved Mike Sr. especially. I remember that I was in Mona’s room at Powerback rehab when I got the positive on my pregnancy test. She was watching an old western on TV. I didn’t tell her at that time. 


As I write this, tears are welling up in my eyes. It should have been so different.


Mona should have been cared for. She should have gotten early medical intervention and treatment of her choosing. Had she, she likely never would have had a stroke. 


Debbie and all of the MOVE 9 should have been honored as they came home. That victory should have been an encouragement for all activists to continue to bring prisoners home and build the world we want to live in.


That summer of 2018, Kevin and I were stunned on the phone as June first told us some of the truth of her life in MOVE. They weren’t nearly the disclosures of this past March of 2021, but they were enough to know that MOVE was not what it says it was. Despite how she was treated, June would not allow others to be hurt. She tirelessly advocated for Mona’s health even against the virulent opposition of Ria and Bert, even though Mona should have done much more to protect all of them as children. Even as they fought her, Ria and Bert continuously relied on June as they couldn’t navigate insurers and providers as she could. 


Just this past spring, as June was planning her escape, she was still figuring out how to carefully transfer Mona’s medical care. 


As I write this, I’m trying to figure out how to conclude. And the reality is, this particular story isn’t over. And there’s no way to make it neat or convenient. It’s tragic. It’s truly tragic. And I’m telling it so that as we all share this knowledge, we can protect each other. 


Mona deserves careful attention to support her health. According to all of the survivors, she also bears some responsibility for what they endured.

 

Debbie and the MOVE 9 deserve so much more than they received in their homecoming. They also know a great deal about the hidden history of MOVE. 


June and the other survivors deserve our protection and support.


I hope we rise to this occasion.



Maiga Milbourne was a dedicated MOVE supporter from 2002-2018. She distanced herself from the group as she began to note troubling patterns within MOVE. In 2021, June Stokes AKA Pixie Africa disclosed severe abuse suffered within MOVE. Together with Maiga’s husband Kevin Price, “Murder at Ryan’s Run” podcast producer Beth McNamara, podcast researcher Bob Helms, and former MOVE members Josh and Whit Robbins, a plan was crafted where June publicly left MOVE with her 5 children and went into hiding. Publicity from both the podcast and this blog has been used to keep her and her children safe.


(from L to R) Janine, Ria, Carlos (top), Mona, (bottom), Janet (middle), Gary (top), Bert (middle), Consuewella

Sunday, July 25, 2021

The Survivors: There's No Neutral on This Moving Train

It’s been 23 days since June Stokes, Whit Sims, and Josh Robbins publicly left the MOVE Organization, drawing attention to child abuse, death threats, financial corruption, and suspicions about connections between MOVE’s leadership and the murder of John Gilbride. Three days later Sara Robbins and Salina Robbins added their names to the public statement. Four days after that Maria Hardy added her name to the statement. All six of them were born into MOVE, and their experiences of being children in MOVE extend from the 1970s to the early 2000s. Other former members and supporters have signed on as well, but my specific focus for this post is the children who were born into MOVE. 

In the over three weeks since Josh, Whit, and June came forward in the group statement, and on the “Murder at Ryan’s Run,” podcast one of the most shocking things has been the media silence. In the past year the Philadelphia Inquirer, Washington Post, The Guardian, The New York Times, and the New Yorker have cumulatively published dozens of stories on MOVE. This is the first time in the nearly 50 year history of MOVE that a group of members have publicly left and yet, as of today, there is still radio silence. When you consider the fact that June (Pixie), who has gone into hiding with her five children, is the daughter of Pam Africa, one of MOVE’s most public figures, this silence becomes even more remarkable. Factor in that Whit is the daughter of the Mike and Debbie Africa of the MOVE 9 and is the sister of MOVE spokesperson Mike Africa Jr (the subject of the HBO documentary “40 Years a Prisoner”) and the silence is astonishing. 

A similar silence is also echoing from many of the activist circles that have worked alongside MOVE for decades. The thing that's so frustrating, sad, and infuriating about this is that these incredibly brave survivors are the ones who are actually living the righteous values that MOVE has attracted people by claiming to represent. For a variety of reasons the abuse that people raised in MOVE have experienced (which is in no way limited to the six who have been brave enough to come forward) is being disclosed slowly. One reason is that much of what they experienced is so horrific that it would almost seem unbelievable if it were all explained at once. I know that when June started disclosing her experiences to my wife, Maiga, and me, we were destabilized for days. When I started talking with Josh and Whit those feelings of shock only deepened. 

However, with what’s already on the record it’s incredibly disappointing to me that these survivors and whistleblowers aren’t receiving more support and attention. Here are just a few of the things that have been disclosed so far: that June was forced into an arranged marriage and forced into pregnancy at the age of 12, that Whit and many other young teenage girls were also forced into marriage and pregnancy, that privilege within MOVE is granted based on skin tone and that darker-skinned children are treated significantly worse, that pregnant teenage girls are forcibly denied medical care even if their lives are in danger, that homophobia within MOVE is so extreme that kids feel that if they were to come out as gay that it may be punishable by death, that Alberta Africa lives a lavish lifestyle with MOVE money while many in MOVE grew up far below the poverty line, that children in MOVE are systematically denied an education, and some, like Josh, have been intentionally denied even basic levels of literacy. 

I really believed that when people had access to this information that the response would be overwhelming support which would help these survivors to transition through this incredibly difficult phase where they’re publicly processing decades of extreme trauma. I understand that people who have publicly supported MOVE for years may have a difficult time integrating this information. However, these survivors are also stating that MOVE’s history is not what you have been led to believe. Last night I was texting with June about her current situation and she said “This is definitely harder than I could have ever imagined.” In reference to the number of people who are trying to maintain a neutral position, she said: “...how so many people are turning a blind eye. It makes me feel like I will never truly escape that fucking cult. Like no matter how hard I try they will win in the end. Even though they are not around we are still being affected by them, and Bert told me that I would never truly escape them even if I did get away alive. I guess this is what she meant because they worked overtime to make sure all of our lives would be hard.”

I wonder how many people could stand at the sidelines if they were on the other end of the phone while people raised in MOVE cried while telling the stories of their life. If people heard how many of them refuse to say the name “John Africa” and instead refer to him as “that man,” or “that evil man.” Many of the survivors have recorded hours of testimony for the “Murder at Ryan’s Run” podcast and much of that will be heard as episodes are released. However, it shouldn’t be necessary. We shouldn’t have to hear the cries of the victims in order to come to their aid. They don’t owe us the theater of their stories. Many people have profited financially, socially, and politically from association with MOVE, and much of that was on the backs of those who were raised in MOVE. They are owed so much more support than they are being given. 

A few months ago I met Josh at a diner to share a meal and talk about how all of this might play out. He passionately spoke about how he would do anything in his power to prevent anyone else from ever experiencing what he has. He specifically talked about the danger that young women in MOVE face, and about how the abuse that they suffer makes them prey for abusive men even if they are able to make it out of MOVE. He swore that he would never allow his daughters to be exposed to what his sisters and nieces had endured, and he questioned how any adult in MOVE ever stood by silently and allowed the abuse to continue. Josh has made tremendous sacrifices in order to share the most vulnerable details of his life. He is demonstrating unimaginable virtue and strength. 

Whit is the oldest of those who were born in MOVE to come forward. She was a small child in the house on Powelton Village during the confrontation on August 8th, 1978 that resulted in her parents serving 40 years in prison. She also lived in the house on Osage Ave. in the early 1980s, and she and her brother Mike would have likely been in the house on May 13th, 1985 if her grandmother Laverne hadn’t fought tooth and nail to get them out. Despite all that she has endured she is one of the kindest, most open-hearted people I have ever had the honor to know. She has risked the possible loss of family members and is putting the most vulnerable and intimate details of her life forward in order to stop the abuse. She has consistently said that she wants to honor the memory of the children who died on Osage Ave. by setting the record straight. She was also willing to take tremendous risks in order to protect the others who are coming forward. 

Of all of those coming forward, June has had her life threatened most directly and repeatedly by Alberta. June left with her five children and is still in hiding. Anyone who remembers seeing her perform with the “Seeds of Wisdom” as a small child knows that June is a force to reckon with. She has been pushing back against the abuse that Bert and Ria preside over since she was a small child. She was married off and forced into pregnancy at the youngest age, 12, in order to try to control her. Alberta often told her that if her power could be harnessed “for the Organization” then she would be one of MOVE’s most valuable soldiers. Instead, June took her strong, independent spirit and fought valiantly to stop the fifty-year pattern of abuse. 

In 1981 Valerie Brown rose in the middle of the night and quietly awakened her small children. She collected a small bag of clothes that she had hidden. Valerie quietly crept down the stairs, children in tow, and walked out of MOVE headquarters at 6221 Osage Ave. never to return. They hopped into the car in the darkness of night and drove away to begin new lives. Had Valerie not risked being caught and punished severely, if she had not fled, then her children likely would have perished in that house four years later (this 1985 interview with Valerie Brown hints at many of the patterns of abuse in MOVE that have been hiding in plain sight). 

In 1998 John Gilbride quickly and quietly packed his things at the Cherry Hill house he shared with his wife Alberta Africa. When he left the house he was so paranoid that he would be caught that he thought the mailman may have been a MOVE informant. He drove away and wished he would never have to return, but he still needed to get his son Zack out safely. Soon after, John filed for divorce and custody for Zack. He fought a four-year battle for custody of his son, and the night before a court-ordered unsupervised visit he was shot multiple times at point-blank range in front of his apartment in Maple Shade, New Jersey. 

These are only two of many dozens of people who have quietly fled MOVE. Many of them were embarrassed or ashamed about having been involved in a cult. Some are still terrified to talk about their experiences. This is the first time in MOVE history that people are leaving MOVE publicly and banding together. This is the first time that strength in numbers is giving individuals the ability to tell their stories publicly, no matter how painful and difficult it is. The work they are doing is protecting so many young people from further abuse, is honoring the deceased children who also suffered abuse in MOVE, and is clearing a path for those who will follow behind. In years to come, I think the larger culture will come to understand the power, significance, and importance of this story. I think that in time many will come to view these survivors as heroes. However, they need all of our support right now. 


Saturday, July 24, 2021

Support the Survivors - Fundraising Help is Needed

We're so grateful to all of those who have donated so graciously to the fundraisers for June Stokes (Pixie) and Maria Hardy. We're hoping that we can raise the $6000 needed for Maria to safely resettle out of Philly within the next week and that people can provide ongoing support for June, and her five kids, as they resettle and find safety. They both need much more financial support in order to build new lives. Also, if you know of women's groups or any other organizations that could help, please pass this info along. 

It's hard to overemphasize how heroic and brave the actions of June, Josh, Whit, Sara, Salina, and Maria are. They took tremendous risks publicly telling their stories. You'll be hearing much more from them. They've faced potentially losing family members and other loved ones, faced the possibility of physical harm, and have been emotionally vulnerable publicly while processing deep trauma. In taking these actions they've protected other children in MOVE, defended themselves, cleared a path for others leaving cults, and have broken a destructive pattern that has run through MOVE for nearly 50 years. Please support them in any way you can.

* Here's June's GoFundMe - you can also donate through June's CashApp at $sheaganics, or June's Venmo at @JuneS2021

* Here's Maria's GoFundMe - You can also donate to Maria on Venmo at @Maria-Hardy-5@


This is from June's GoFundMe:
Pixie Africa/June Stokes has suffered serious abuse within the cult known as the MOVE Organization. On Friday, July 2nd, Pixie publicly spoke out against the group and with her 5 children, went into hiding. This GoFundMe is to provide funding for basic life needs while Pixie and her children are in hiding for their own safety.

During their first two weeks in hiding, their expenses were especially high as they had to be in short-term housing without using any of Pixie's accounts to completely protect their location. They are in more stable housing (for now) but still need community support to meet their needs. Pixie is currently caring for 5 kids while going through one of the greatest traumas of their lives. She is reliving what she endured within the MOVE cult as she tells her story and others learn it while prioritizing being a mother to her children. They need community funds to help cover food, entertainment for the kids, clothing, household needs, gas, mental health therapy, and more as they navigate this crisis. Help them through this time as they set up lives independent of MOVE for the first time ever.

This is from Maria's GoFundMe:
Maria Hardy, formally known as Maria Africa, was born into the MOVE organization. She recently decided to publicly come forward to tell her story through the blog, Leaving MOVE, and the podcast, Murder at Ryan’s Run. By coming forward to reveal her truth Maria (along with other Ex-MOVE members) shed light on abuses including arranged child “marriages”, forced child pregnancy, and emotional/psychological abuse experienced by children in the organization. As you may have heard in the podcast episode she was featured in, Maria is concerned for her safety and hopes to put the trauma of her time in MOVE behind her. She doesn’t want this experience to define her and is working to pursue a long-held dream of moving away from Philadelphia where she won't be exposed to daily reminders of abuse. $6,000 will help Maria reach this goal and will sustain her for a few months while she looks for sustainable income away from Philadelphia.

The survivors of MOVE ask that the greater community show up in support to help them (and any other members who come forward) find their own definition of freedom and liberation. All funds will be directly deposited from this platform to Maria.

If you have any remote working opportunities that would help Maria sustain her future please comment below. Any help you can offer is greatly appreciated. Thank you for contributing. Please share this link widely.

Friday, July 23, 2021

"MOVE is now the father": Reflections on Episode 2

A great deal of this piece is in reference to the second episode of “Murder at Ryan’s Run.” If you haven’t listened to it yet please do that first. It’s a very important episode. 


I just finished listening to the second episode of the “Murder at Ryan’s Run” podcast, “A is for Anarchism,” and many things jump out immediately. The first is how different Andino Ward is from how he was described to me within MOVE. Andino is the father of the child who in MOVE came to be known as Birdie Africa. Birdie was born as Oyewolffe to Andino and his wife Rhonda. Soon after Oyewolffe was born Rhonda encountered MOVE and was pulled in deeply very quickly. Andino struggled to find his son for a decade and was prevented from having any contact with his son by MOVE. The next time that Andino saw his son was in the hospital on May 13th, 1985. His son was the only child to make it out of the fires of the MOVE house on Osage Ave. alive. 


The image of Andino Ward presented within MOVE is a far cry from the man I heard speaking on the podcast. According to MOVE leadership Andino just “loves the system,” “loves cops,” and didn’t love his son at all. They claimed that the only reason Andino wanted custody of his son was that he “hates MOVE” and not because he loved his son. MOVE leadership talked about Oyewolffe, the person they called Birdie, as if he was MOVE's child that Andino, his father, had stolen. They talked about Andino this way when Birdie was mentioned, especially around May 13th, and with most frequency right after Birdie passed away in 2013. The lies told about Andino mirror the lies that were told about John Gilbride as the rhetoric that was used against John was nearly identical and just as far from the truth.  


Hearing from Andino in this episode it’s easy to understand why MOVE would want to poison people against him. According to Andino, when his wife, Rhonda, joined MOVE and took their son with her, John Africa forbade Andino from ever seeing his son again. In the mid-70s Andino was told by MOVE “just because you’re the biological father doesn’t make you the father.” According to them, MOVE was now his son’s father. The first time he approached MOVE headquarters and shouted at the gates that he needed to see his son he was chased down the street by MOVE men with hatchets. The second time he approached he was shot at. He asked the authorities for help many times and has stated “No one wanted to do anything on my behalf”.


In 1980, five years after his son went missing, he finally tracked down Rhonda in Holmesburg prison. When he asked his estranged wife where their son was she told him “If you continue to look for him they will kill him rather than give him to you.” All of this is shocking and difficult to believe, especially in contrast with the family-oriented image that MOVE presents of itself. However, this pattern closely mirrors the experience John Gilbride had when trying to fight MOVE leader, Alberta Africa for custody of their son Zack. And it’s not just John Gilbride, there are many fathers who have had similar experiences with MOVE. As we proceed you will be hearing from more of them. 


If you look back at old newspaper articles from MOVE’s history in the 70s and 80s it’s clear that these patterns have always existed. The cult control that's being documented on this blog and in the podcast is not a result of the leadership of Alberta Africa but has existed since MOVE’s inception. However, for all of MOVE’s history, one person left at a time, and most were afraid or ashamed to talk about their experiences. Most fathers who were driven away from their children were not able to see all of those who had come before them. This is the first time in the nearly fifty-year history of MOVE that a group of people is leaving publicly and telling their stories. When looked at from this perspective, extreme stories like those of Andino Ward or John Gilbride are seen not as anomalies but as part of a pattern. 


Within MOVE, children become the property of MOVE. Couples are often set against one another by MOVE leadership and the children are groomed by those leaders. I know the first part of that equation firsthand because I split from MOVE intellectually in 2007 but stayed in to preserve my marriage. Once I showed my hand that I was no longer a true believer, Ria and Bert worked hard to try to turn my wife and me against one another so that I would leave and she would stay. I was fortunate that we didn’t have a child at the time, otherwise, I would have found myself in a similar position to Andino Ward, John Gilbride, and many others. When women with children try to leave MOVE they’re told that they can leave but their kids have to stay. This is what Alberta told June (Pixie) when she tried to escape without the protection of going public. Looking back at MOVE’s history now it’s clear that these stories have always been hiding in plain sight. It’s my hope that as the patterns become clearer the children born in MOVE will be protected and supported, and that the Gilbride family will finally get justice. 


John Gilbride with his son Zack